Normally, this is informed me once the graphic license to the author’s area
Often whenever dates are provided, he could be offered having 1 day of your few days that really does not suits thereupon go out whilst during the genuine history. One particular example happens in Harry Potter as well as the Prisoner of Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney relates to 16 October because the Friday, even when 16 October 1993 was a friday.
There are also contradictions when you look at the guides in this region. For example, in Harry Potter additionally the Cup off Flame, both 1 September and you may dos September are offered given that Mondays and you will, inside the Harry Potter together with Prisoner out-of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is decided into 20 April, but mindful parsing of your text message indicates that it may has actually took place no after than February.
In addition to, when you look at the Harry Potter additionally the Goblet out of Flame they say that the Winners had been chosen to the Friday 30 October, but 29 October are a saturday for the 1994.
In a bankruptcy proceeding out-of Quidditch From Decades, they do say that the basic Quidditch World Glass happened within the 1473. If for example the title was stored all the four years, it disputes towards declaration into the Goblet out-of Flames that 1994 World Cup is the brand new 422nd. If the Quidditch Through the Ages is right, the fresh new 422nd Quidditch Business Mug manage in reality fall-in the year 3161, but if Goblet regarding Flames is great, the initial Community Cup got kept inside 306.
Historic problems [ ]
While the show, with regards to the schedule produced from the newest Chamber from Gifts source, is set on 1990s, the brand new show usually seems as if it’s invest this new late 1990s to help you middle-2000s, approximately concurrent into guide of the guides. Into the Harry Potter in addition to 50 % of-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to mention to your “predecessor” of Finest Minister of the British. With regards to the over timeline, this should occur in the summer regarding 1996, if the Perfect Minister was John Biggest, whoever instant predecessor try a woman (is the reason earliest interviewing Fudge, the ebook says the latest election, however, Biggest wasn’t first decided on and only got more than shortly after Thatcher retired.
You’ll be able to, not unlikely, you to definitely Fudge would be speaking about a very faraway ancestor, since Thatcher grabbed work environment in advance of Fudge allegedly turned Minister getting Magic. (Regardless if you can believe a scenario where Fudge is delegated by the Minister to have Secret to meet on the Best Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller workplace.) In Latin gГјzel kД±zlar addition, the identity and you can history of the prime Minister represented generally seems to even more closely fits regarding Tony Blair than simply out-of John Major. An article on Every day Mail cards one to Rowling is actually romantic on upcoming-Chancellor of your Exchequer Gordon Brownish (usually considered an opponent to help you Blair’s leaders of your own Labor Party, exactly who succeeded your and turned Best Minister), and this she has been wanting to tell you Blair’s bad top. In the event the courses was basically set in sync which have guide time from Philosopher’s Brick, then it experience carry out occur in 2002 (after Blair turned Best Minister).
But not, it was after reported that twenty two November is actually a monday, which it was at 1994
An identical condition relates to Nicolas Flamel, who was simply mentioned to be 665 during the time of new earliest guide, but Nicolas Flamel is a bona-fide historic contour and you will won’t reach one to age up to 1996, around the go out the original publication was authored. The rebuttal for it is the fact that day the brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel was created doesn’t correspond with this new Nicolas Flamel of Harry Potter.
A new situation is present of Rubeus Hagrid’s period due to the fact Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s suggested regarding the series you to definitely Hagrid received you to condition within a couple of years away from his expulsion off school inside 1942. In that scene of Harry Potter while the Cup off Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces about Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper appear to overlap that have Molly’s ages in school, it appears to be impractical you to definitely she recalls a previous gamekeeper. Although not, it’s possible that Hagrid failed to feel a beneficial gamekeeper instantly immediately after are expelled, but alternatively come since the Ogg’s assistant. This might be plausible given that whenever Harry believes which he often become expelled to possess traveling towards broomstick in the place of consent inside the first year, the guy magic in the event that he would be allowed to remain on since the Hagrid’s assistant.
halil yıldız